Best Vegan Cheese for Grilled Cheese: Top Picks for a Delicious Melt

Grilled cheese is a classic comfort food, and the key to making a great vegan version lies in choosing the right cheese substitute. In this article, we will explore some of the best vegan cheese options that melt beautifully and are full of flavor, ensuring that your grilled cheese is not only cruelty-free but also delicious and satisfying.

Selecting a vegan cheese that complements your preferred bread and fillings is crucial for achieving that indulgent, gooey sandwich we all adore. Understanding which vegan cheeses perform best when heated can elevate their grilled cheese game and satisfy their cravings without compromising their values or dietary needs.

Understanding Vegan Cheese for Grilled Cheese

Choosing the right vegan cheese is of utmost importance when making the perfect vegan grilled cheese. This section will discuss the factors that make vegan cheese suitable for grilled cheese and the significance of melting and cheese pull.

What Makes a Vegan Cheese Suitable for Grilled Cheese

Not all vegan cheeses are created equal; some are better suited for grilled cheese sandwiches than others. Key factors to consider when selecting a vegan cheese for grilled cheese include:

  • Texture: The cheese should have a texture similar to dairy-based cheese, allowing it to spread and melt evenly when heated.
  • Flavor: A delicious taste is essential since cheese is one of the primary components of a grilled cheese sandwich. The flavor should not be overly artificial or overpowering.
  • Melting ability: Vegan cheese should have the ability to melt and become gooey when heated, like traditional cheese.

The Importance of Melting and Cheese Pull

Melting and cheese pull are crucial aspects of a satisfying grilled cheese sandwich. These factors contribute to the overall texture and mouthfeel of the sandwich, making it a comforting and indulgent treat.

The term “cheese pull” refers to the long, stretchy strands of melted cheese that form when you pull apart a grilled cheese sandwich. This desirable quality adds visual appeal and fun to the classic grilled cheese experience. Good vegan cheese should exhibit this characteristic, as it enhances the overall enjoyment of the sandwich.

While selecting a vegan cheese for grilled cheese, choosing one with excellent melting properties is essential. Melting ensures that the cheese becomes smooth and creamy, ultimately melding seamlessly with the other ingredients in the sandwich. Experiment with different vegan cheese options to find the ideal flavor, texture, and meltability for your perfect vegan grilled cheese sandwich.

Top Vegan Cheese Brands and Options

When seeking the perfect vegan cheese for grilled cheese sandwiches, several brands and options are available to ensure a satisfying and delicious experience. Here, we will explore some top choices and their distinctive features.

Daiya Cheddar-Style Slices

Daiya offers cheddar-style slices, a popular vegan alternative to traditional cheddar cheese. These slices are:

  • Made from plant-based ingredients
  • Free from dairy, soy, and gluten
  • Retailing in many grocery stores

These slices melt beautifully in a grilled cheese sandwich, providing the familiar, tangy cheddar flavor many enjoy.

Field Roast Creamy Original Chao Slices

Field Roast’s Creamy Original Chao Slices is another exceptional choice for tasty vegan cheese. These slices:

  • Contain a unique, coconut-based fermentation
  • Are infused with traditional Vietnamese chao tofu
  • Offer a creamy texture with a savory, tangy taste

Chao Slices melt smoothly in a grilled cheese and add a mouthwatering depth of flavor.

Violife Just Like Smoked Provolone Slices

Violife’s Just Like Smoked Provolone Slices are a perfect option for those who desire a smoky twist to their vegan grilled cheese. These slices:

  • Are non-GMO and free from soy and gluten
  • Feature a delicious, smoky flavor

This vegan provolone is a great way to elevate your grilled cheese with a sophisticated smoky taste.

Miyoko’s Vegan Mozzarella

Miyoko’s Vegan Mozzarella is an excellent dairy-free alternative for those who crave a creamy, gooey grilled cheese sandwich. This mozzarella:

  • Is cashew-based and gluten-free
  • Melts to a perfect, stretchy consistency
  • Delivers a mild and buttery flavor

Miyoko’s mozzarella enhances a grilled cheese experience by offering a rich texture and mild taste.

Vegan American and Smoked Gouda Cheese

For those who seek more traditional vegan cheese options, American and smoked Gouda varieties provide an enjoyable, close-to-authentic experience. These cheeses:

  • Replicate the classic taste and texture of their non-vegan counterparts
  • Are widely available from various vegan brands
  • Melt comfortably in a grilled cheese sandwich

Whether you’re a fan of the classic American cheese flavor or the distinctive tang of smoked Gouda, these vegan alternatives offer an assortment of satisfying options for your grilled cheese cravings.

Nutrition and Ingredients in Vegan Cheese

Vegan cheese, with its plant-based and dairy-free ingredients, has been gaining popularity as a healthier and more ethical alternative to traditional dairy-based cheese. This section delves into the nutritional content, common ingredients, and potential allergens in vegan cheese.

Protein and Saturated Fat Content

Regarding protein content, plant-based cheeses vary depending on their primary ingredient. For example, vegan cheese made from cashews or seeds may contain more protein than coconut oil or tapioca starch. However, they may not reach the same level of protein found in dairy-based cheese.

Saturated fat content is another important aspect to consider. Coconut-based cheeses often have higher levels of saturated fat due to the coconut oil used as the primary ingredient. In contrast, cheeses from nuts or seeds may contain less saturated fat.

It’s essential to compare the nutrition labels of different vegan cheese options to select the one that aligns best with your dietary needs.

Common Ingredients and Allergens

Vegan cheese ingredients differ widely depending on the product and manufacturer. Some common ingredients found in plant-based cheese include:

  • Nuts (like cashews)
  • Seeds
  • Nutritional yeast
  • Tapioca starch
  • Coconut oil
  • Calcium

These ingredients allow vegan cheese to achieve a similar texture and flavor profile to traditional dairy cheese, all while being dairy and gluten-free. However, allergens may still be present. Nuts, for example, are prevalent allergens found in certain vegan cheese varieties. Soy-free options are also available for people who are sensitive to soy products.

It is crucial to read the ingredient list carefully before purchasing and consuming vegan cheese, especially if you have an allergy or sensitivity.

When shopping for vegan cheeses, look for certifications and labels like non-GMO, organic, and gluten-free to ensure you get a product that aligns with your dietary preferences and requirements.

Pairings for the Perfect Vegan Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Creating the ultimate vegan grilled cheese sandwich goes beyond just selecting the right vegan cheese. Choosing bread, butter, and accompanying dishes can elevate your sandwich experience.

Vegan Bread and Butter Recommendations

Start by choosing a high-quality vegan bread with a hearty texture that will hold up well when grilled. Some popular options include whole wheat, sourdough, or multigrain bread. Be sure to look for bread labeled as vegan, as some may contain honey or other animal-derived ingredients.

For that rich, buttery flavor, choose a vegan butter or spread made from plant-based oils such as coconut, olive, or avocado oil. Many vegan butter brands are free of animal-derived ingredients and unhealthy additives while providing a similar taste and texture to traditional butter.

Here are some great vegan bread and butter pairings:

  • Whole wheat bread with olive oil-based vegan butter
  • Sourdough bread with coconut oil-based vegan butter
  • Multigrain bread with avocado oil-based vegan butter

Soup and Side Dish Ideas

A warm, comforting soup is the classic accompaniment for a grilled cheese sandwich, and there are plenty of vegan options. Enjoy your sandwich with a bowl of hearty vegetable soup, tomato bisque, or creamy vegan mushroom soup for a satisfying lunch or dinner.

In addition to soups, consider pairing your vegan grilled cheese with a light and flavorful salad, roasted vegetables, or a side of oven-baked sweet potato fries. These sides can provide balance and contrast to the richness of the sandwich.

Here are some soup and side dish ideas to complement your vegan grilled cheese:

SoupSide Dish
Hearty vegetable soupLight and flavorful salad
Tomato bisqueRoasted vegetables
Creamy vegan mushroom soupOven-baked sweet potato fries

Explore different vegan bread, butter, and side dishes combinations to create the perfect vegan grilled cheese sandwich experience. Don’t be afraid to get creative with your pairings and discover new flavors that will please your taste buds.

Unique Vegan Grilled Cheese Ideas

There are countless ways to make delicious and satisfying vegan grilled cheese sandwiches by combining plant-based cheeses and other non-dairy alternatives. Incorporating various ingredients ensures you will enjoy a rich, creamy, and flavorsome sandwich that meets your vegan dietary preferences.

Incorporating Vegan Cream Cheese and Other Spreads

Vegan cream cheese is popular for adding creaminess and meltability to grilled cheese sandwiches. Derived from alternative sources, such as nuts or soy, it provides a dairy-free option perfect for those on a vegan diet. Combine vegan cream cheese with dairy-free alternatives like plant-based cheddar or other vegan cheese options to create the ultimate grilled cheese.

Some popular dairy-free cheese spreads to consider:

  • Vegan cream cheese
  • Vegan cheddar cheese
  • Plant-based cheese alternatives

Utilizing Avocado, Fermented Tofu, and More

Avocado is a fantastic addition to a vegan grilled cheese sandwich. With its buttery texture and nutrient-rich composition, avocado can lend a beautifully creamy feel while providing essential nutrients for those adhering to a vegan diet.

Another unconventional ingredient to consider incorporating into your grilled cheese sandwich is fermented tofu. Also known as stinky tofu, this rich and pungent fermented tofu provides a unique taste and texture to a traditional grilled cheese sandwich.

Consider experimenting with different plant-based cheese combinations to achieve a variety of flavors and textures in your sandwiches:

  • Avocado with plant-based cheeses
  • Combination of vegan cheddar and mature cheddar alternatives
  • Fermented tofu for a unique twist


What are the best vegan cheese brands for grilled cheese?

  • Chao Creamery by Field Roast
  • Daiya Mozzarella and Cheddar Shreds
  • Miyoko’s Creamery Vegan Mozzarella
  • Follow Your Heart American and Provolone Slices

Can vegan cheese melt and stretch like real cheese?

Many vegan cheeses are designed with melting and stretching in mind, making them suitable for grilled cheese sandwiches. Always check the brand’s label for melting advice.

What are some common ingredients in vegan cheese?

Nutritional YeastProvides a savory, cheesy flavor and is fortified with B vitamins.
Cashews or AlmondsUsed as a base to create a creamy, smooth texture.
Tapioca StarchGives a stretchy, elastic quality to vegan cheese.
Agar-Agar or CarrageenanVegetable-derived gelatin alternatives that help vegan cheese solidify.

Is vegan cheese healthier than dairy cheese?

Vegan cheeses can be lower in fat and cholesterol than dairy cheeses and are lactose-free. However, it’s essential to check the label for sodium and nutritional content, as they can vary between brands.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *